Too much time on their hands

Hi Brit,

Y’all appear to have people with too much time on their hands, Fat dog pair convicted of cruelty.  This would seem to include the judge who allowed the case into court, assuming your judges have that authority.  It would be interesting to know how the RSPCA (related to our SPCA?) picked this particular dog to be concerned about. 

And, with a quick bit of research, I found a potential answer; England has Pet Nazis!  About the RSPCA – RSPCA today.  Which makes me even more confused about how things work over there.  If this is a charitable non-government organization, how do they have any inspection or enforcement power?  Can one of their uniformed thugs just waltz into your home and check out your pet?  Can just anyone off the street bring you to court on a criminal charge?  No wonder y’all don’t have laws against jaywalking.  A little help please.

the Grit


10 Responses to “Too much time on their hands”

  1. Anne Kasica Says:

    Take a look at

    which is our website. We run a helpline for people who have difficulties with the RSPCA. You will also find lots of information on the RSPCA-Animadversion website

    which details such interesting facts as the RSPCA has a criminal conviction for perverting the course of justice for which offence they were fined £10,000, and that they actually tried to blackmail someone into giving false evidence in order to obtain a conviction – the transcript of the tape of that attempt is on the site.

    And yes, these people are permitted to bring private prosecutions in the courts. Worse, the new Animal Welfare Act 2006 may well empower them to have right of entry! It will depend on the local authority or the Minister at the time.

    Hope this helps


  2. britandgrit Says:

    Hi Anne,

    And thanks! Actually, I finally got talk to my wife, a veterinarian, about the subject and she filled me in on some of the oddities. While I am a great animal lover, most of our pets are rescue animals that no one else would adopt, there need to be limits. I was also taken aback by the difference in the British system and ours! Which is why I love having the Brit as a partner. Otherwise, this difference in our laws would have zipped right over my head.

    I will look up the Animal Welfare Act 2006 first thing in the morning (I’ve listed it on my notepad), and, I suspect, my partner may have something to say about it as well.

    Once again, thanks much for taking the time to comment! If there is anything else on this subject, or, heck, any subject, you want us to write about, drop us an email.

    the Grit (and our 4 dogs and 3 cats 🙂

  3. atthe404 Says:

    You two do not have time to cast your eyes over Part 24 of the Civil; Procedure Rules
    do you? Its a travesty.

  4. britandgrit Says:

    Hi atthe404,

    While I am not at all familiar with the rule you mention, I will most certainly look it up first thing in the morning. After all, I love that sort of thing 😉 Thanks for the comment!

    the Grit

  5. Crazy laws in England « Conversations with Brit & Grit Says:

    […] commented on Too much time on their hands, that we should check out the Animal Welfare Act, which I did.  There’s a link to the actual […]

  6. britandgrit Says:

    Hi atthe404,

    If this,
    ,is what you mean, then I did look it over, and have absolutely no idea what it means. If you know a better site to gain an understanding of this, I’ll be happy to look at it, and more than happy to give my opinion 😉

    the Grit

  7. britandgrit Says:

    I agree with atthe404. The powers of entry in the UK are extremely wide in terms of who can apply for them and, depending upon the local authority can be exercised with little reasonable evidence.

    the Brit

  8. Anne Kasica Says:

    SHG Press Release

    The Fat Dog Case

    The RSPCA failed to alleviate Rusty’s suffering.

    All they achieved was to add the hunger pangs of starvation to the pain of arthritis and hip dysplasia and to separate Rusty from those he loved.


    18th January 2007

    On the eve of Rusty’s return to the Bentons The Self Help Group for Farmers, Pet Owners and Others experiencing difficulties with the RSPCA (The SHG) is breaking its silence on this matter in order to correct the misunderstandings relating to the merits of bringing this prosecution in the light of the statement by Ben Bradshaw, during the final debate before the Animal Welfare Act 2006 (AWA) became law, that

    “It is not the Government’s intention to punish the owners of fat cats, although overfeeding an animal can be problematic”

    Said Ernest Vine of the SHG: “We hope that once the AWA is in force the RSPCA will comply with the intentions of Parliament and will never again bring a case involving an overweight animal before the courts.”

    “Rusty was suffering in the care of the Bentons. Rusty has been suffering in the care of the RSPCA. And Rusty will continue to suffer until the day he dies, irrespective of whose care he is in.”

    “Most of Rusty’s weight gain occurred following an operation to neuter him. Neutered or spayed dogs need 30% less food than unaltered dogs and it is this factor that is contributing to so much obesity in the canine world.”

    “In Rusty’s case this reduction in food intake has to be added to the reduction necessary to account for his inability to exercise because of the pain from his hip dysplasia and severe arthritis and his need to lose weight. The only means by which he can lose weight is for his dietary intake to be restricted.”

    According to Duncan Davidson, the defence vet, Rusty had unusually large amounts of grass in his faeces and was desperate to eat grass when outside. Rusty’s need to eat grass can be explained by Mr. Davidson’s estimation that Rusty needs a 75% reduction of the normal labrador’s dietary intake.

    Anne Kasica said “So the RSPCA have replaced the suffering of being overweight with the suffering of feeling continually starved and desperate to eat. No-one can cure Rusty’s arthritis which is the cause of his obesity. Indeed, if it were so easy to diet Jackie Ballard, the Director General of the RSPCA would have gone through life with a slender waif like build.”

    “Which form of suffering is worse? Rusty cannot walk and exercise even when slimmed down because of his arthritis. And in his twilight years the one pleasure that every Labrador is renowned for enjoying, eating, has been denied him as a result of this ill-judged political prosecution.”

    “The Bentons were found not guilty of causing unnecessary suffering by failing to adequately treat Rusty’s ear condition because with all of the immense resources available to them, the RSPCA had also failed to cure it. Just as they have failed to cure his eye problems and arthritis.”

    Indeed, Rusty had enjoyed treatment paid for by pet insurance for most of his life. But his pet insurance ended when he reached the cut off age. And the Benton’s vets, Pet Doctors, refused to treat Rusty unless they were paid cash up front. Pet Doctors also refused to let the Bentons pay in instalments.

    Said Anne Kasica: “The massive costs of the RSPCA’s treatment regime for Rusty were beyond the purse of any ordinary pet owner. The RSPCA could have offered to help with the cost of veterinary treatment for Rusty but instead chose to spend many thousands of pounds in prosecuting his owners. They put Rusty through further misery by separating him from the people he loved and taking him from the only home he knew.”

    “This case highlights the reasons why people are afraid to approach the RSPCA for help. We have been campaigning for some time for an animal NHS for the animals of pensioners because just when insurance is most needed, when an animal becomes elderly and its owners income drops, is the time insurance is no longer available.

    The SHG urges government to introduce a National Animal Health Service which we believe would do more to reduce animal suffering than all of the animal welfare legislation that has been passed while this government has been in power.

    The SHG urges the government to take steps to control RSPCA prosecutions by requiring them to be scrutinised by the police and CPS before they are allowed to proceed, and we ask the CPS to actively quality control all RSPCA prosecutions by taking over and dropping those which are clearly political or which no responsible prosecutor would bring.
    Notes to Editors: –

    House of Commons Hansard Debates for 06 Nov 2006 (pt 0001)

    The SHG Response to the EIG consultation

    Pudgy pooch lumbers home – The

    Brothers found guilty over ‘grossly’ obese dog,,1989216,00.html?gusrc=rss&feed=11

    Defence Barrister: Ann Marie Gregory of St. Pauls Chambers Leeds

    For further comment please contact Anne Kasica on 01559 371031 or Ernest Vine on 01559 370566. Mobile 07719 367148. e-mail:

    The SHG was officially formed in June 1990 and has been helping people to defend themselves and their animals from the RSPCA ever since. The national help line number is 08700 72 66 89

    A copy of this and previous press releases from The SHG are online at

    Background information on the Self Help Group for Farmers Pet Owners and Other Experiencing Difficulties with the RSPCA can be found at

    Details of further criticisms of the RSPCA can be found at the RSPCA-Animadversion website:


  9. britandgrit Says:

    Hi Anne,

    Wow! Thanks for taking time to get that comment together. I’ll keep my eye on the RSPCA from now on. If you get anything you want us to post about, our email is listed on the sidebar. For that matter, if you ever want to share interesting stuff about being a Barrister, we’d welcome that as well.

    the Grit

  10. Liquid vitamins supplement body balance Says:

    Liquid vitamins supplement body balance

    Liquid vitamins supplement body balance

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: